Hair loss products are becoming more and more popular, with 6% more men and 46 more women experiencing hair thinning and loss as they age. Research puts this down to stress.
There are lots of hair products out there that claim to slow down this process and keep ahead of thick, healthy hair for longer. But do any of them actually work?
Here’s a comparison of two top-of-the-market brands.
Eva Graham founded Nioxin back in 1987. She got the idea from her father when she was young and used to brush his hair, which gradually became thinner.
She used herbal remedies, researched concoctions and test out on herself until she was able to gain the support of real scientists and dermatologists.
Eva was one of the first people to understand that treating the hair wasn’t the solution, it was actually the scalp that needed some extra care and attention.
The brand now markets a whole range of products across the globe to help improve scalp cell turnover and remove dead skin cells to let new hair grow, all formulated using herbal products and remedies, with a little extra.
The brand is proudly known as the non-drug alternative to hair thickening.
Rogaine is an alternative method of keeping those long, flowing locks for longer. However, this does sometimes involve drugs, rather than a simple, external solution.
Though it is easier and less effort for some, it can also come with some side effects.
This method originated in the 1950s when a drug called Minoxidil was developed to get rid of ulcers. This didn’t actually work.
However, scientists discovered that instead of removing ulcers, the drug opened blood vessels to allow for smoother blood flow.
Coincidentally, this helped a lot of people to increase blood flow to their scalp, rejuvenating the cells up there and keeping the hair follicles healthy and growing for longer.
Although Rogaine doesn’t claim to completely remove the threat of baldness, it has been proven to help and was developed into a serum in the 1980s to be used on the scalp as well as internally.
Nioxin & Rogaine General Differences And Similarities
- Neither brand claims to be able to solve the problem permanently but may help to boost your scalp health to help you maintain hair for longer.
- Nioxin is filled with natural ingredients that can help you feel good about your treatment.
- Rogaine needs to be used regularly to maintain the effects, though some people can experience side effects of this.
- Rogaine products are unscented, meaning no one will know you’re using them.
Nioxin Vs Rogaine for Hair Growth
To stimulate new hair growth, it’s important to ensure that the cells in the scalp are constantly refreshed and have great blood flowing to them.
Nioxin approaches this externally, while Rogaine promotes better blood flow from underneath the skin.
Both products have been dermatologically tested and are approved by the FDA. They have been proven to increase the likelihood of hair regrowth, even in elderly people.
Both products also offer different ranges of products based on males and females to cater to the differences in hormones that may affect the hair follicles.
Nioxin aims to treat the scalp to make it healthier by removing old, dead cells and opening space for new follicles to push through.
This means that regular washing and treating the scalp with these products will help hair to grow for longer, as your skin is genuinely healthier.
It may take a while to see the effects of Nioxin, but the constant use is unlikely to have any negative effects unless you have allergies.
Rogaine tablets can treat other issues within the body through medication so it can make you lifestyle better with the added bonus of hair growth as it stimulates more blood flow to the scalp.
The serum or foaming gel developed can also have lasting effects too, though they are more chemical-heavy, focusing on the original ingredient minoxidil, meaning they can be quite potent and affect other areas of the body if not used sparingly.
The drug needs to be in the system to see the effects, you’ll need to take it constantly to see a constant change.
Taking regular medication can also have side effects and some people experience itchiness of the eyes and redness of the treated area.
But the product does claim to show clear hair growth in around 3 months from the first day that you take it.
If you’re looking for a more natural remedy without any knock-on effects on your overall health, then Nioxin is the one for you. Although, you will need to be patient as this isn’t a quick fix.
However, once you have the right product, you’re likely to see hair growth for much longer and maintain it, even if you stop using the product for a while.
Rogaine is a quicker fix. It claims to show effects within just 3 months of use.
However, it can have side effects on your eyes and other areas of skin which could also be detrimental to your health and the benefits are likely to reduce much more quickly if you stop using it.
For overall health reasons, the Nioxin approach must be the front-runner here.
Nioxin Vs Rogaine Serum
Rogaine presents the 2% minoxidil Topical Solution. It comes in both a male and female version which caters specifically to the different needs of men and women.
It’s simple to use, by just applying a few drops of the solution to the areas with thinning hair.
Nioxin’s Scalp Protect Serum contains active ingredients to help reduce irritation on the skin and freshen up the cells, removing dead skin.
Both products work to make the scalp healthier and promote regrowth quickly and seamlessly, no matter what type of hair you have.
The Rogaine product is a concentrated formula designed to give the fastest hair regrowth and provide ultimate satisfaction.
It works by stimulating the blood flow under the scalp to make hair follicles more active and healthier.
The Nioxin product focuses on the surface of the skin, removing dead skin cells and paving the way for new hair growth. It does a great job of protecting the skin from dirt, keeping it clear and rested, and helping new, healthy hair to form.
If it’s used in the right quantities, the Rogaine serum is likely to give you faster and more reliable results.
This is because the natural elements of the Nioxin version, while they protect the scalp from damage, don’t do much to speed up the growth like the Rogaine.
New hair, in this case, will likely come through in 4-6 months, while the Rogaine can offer results within 3 months.
Nioxin Vs Rogaine for Allergies
When it comes to trying out new products on the skin or using medication, it’s important to ensure that your body won’t react in an adverse way that could cause the problem to become worse.
Nioxin offers the Nioxin Scalp Recovery Anti-Dandruff System Kit which comes with natural green tea extract to help your scalp recover and sooth redness or dry spots.
This helps to make the skin’s surface healthier and promotes regrowth. Because it’s formulated with a natural ingredient foundation, it’s less likely to cause allergic reactions, even for people with sensitive skin.
The ROGAINE® 5% Minoxidil Unscented Foam is a spray-on formula that starts working immediately and over 80% of people who use it have seen a difference within a few months.
This option comes alongside the concentrated serum that Rogaine offers and it’s a better option if you suffer from skin irritation or allergies.
This is because the foam comes right out of the bottle and there’s no need for it to touch other areas of the skin – even your hands.
Neither product is known to cause allergic reactions very often and is both clinically tested and approved by the FDA to be safe to use on most skin types.
Because Rogaine is more concentrated when using the foam or serum, it can affect other areas of the body if not used sparingly.
If too much of the solution or foam is used on areas of the face or arms while washing, it can cause redness or itchy spots and sometimes even skin peeling for people with particularly sensitive skin.
It is also known to lower blood pressure and cause headaches in severe cases.
Because of the more concentrated formula, Rogaine may help to regrow hair a little faster. However, this can come at a price if you’re prone to allergies.
If you choose Rogaine and often experience flaky skin, you may need to try using gloves when you apply it.
For this reason, the Nioxin recovery kit is the preferred option alongside the shampoo and serum. There are more products involved in encouraging hair growth, which is likely to cost a little extra.
The results may also take a little longer. However, due to the gentler formula incorporating natural ingredients, it’s a much kinder option if you’re prone to allergies.
Nioxin Vs Rogaine for Different Hair Types
People with all hair types can lose their hair. It could be through age, stress, or trauma. So, the product you choose to thicken or grow back hair needs to be something that will work for your hair type.
Rogaine offers a one size fits all option with a single course of treatment, whereas Nioxin offers different hair care regimes depending on hair type.
Both Rogaine and Nioxin can work for all hair types for regrowth. Although Nioxin cares for the external skin cells and Rogaine approaches the problem from within, they can still achieve regrowth or improvement for most people.
Rogaine recommends a single drug or serum combination to grow your hair back.
It doesn’t take into consideration the different hair type you have. But does this matter? Sure, you’ll get more hair growth, and it will grow the same color and texture as your natural hair.
However, the treatment doesn’t aim to look after the hair once it’s grown.
Nioxin, on the other hand, focuses on the scalp and skincare to promote new growth and has different shampoo and conditioning ranges to take care of the new hair once it’s grown.
Their range of shampoo systems, cleansers, and anti-dandruff kits help you to keep the hair healthy and more vibrant. They even offer a range that specifically caters for colored hair.
In this case, if you’re looking for a product to keep your hair shiny, sleek, and youthful the Nioxin products are by far the better option. There is a range of products suitable for every hair type to ensure your hair is taken care of long-term.
The Rogaine will grow your hair, sure, but the aftercare will need to be taken care of by other branded products alongside it.
Overall, if you’re looking for a product that’s a little more natural, great for allergies and all skin types, and gives you long-lasting effects, then the Nioxin is the way to go.
You’ll need to test out some of the products to get the exact right combination for your skin and hair and the effects won’t be as instant as they would be with Rogaine.
However, you’ll get a more natural feel, fewer side effects, and a result that can last, even if you choose to stop using it for a while. It works to enliven the scalp for longer, giving you a younger look, and a younger feeling too.