If you’re a mom (or dad), chances are we have given you a tube (or six) of baby cream at some point. With all the options on the market, it’s hard to know which one to choose.
Today, we’re going to compare two of the most popular baby creams: Mustela and Aveeno. Both are hypoallergenic and designed for newborns, but some key differences are. So, which one is right for your little one? Let’s inspect!
Aveeno is a product that comes from Johnson & Johnson, a company that was created in 1886 by brothers Robert Wood and James McNeill.
They started their business by selling food items such as starch, sugar, cornmeal, and oatmeal under the name “Johnson’s Prepared Flour”. In 1894, they discovered their first medical breakthrough with the invention of the world’s first surgical dressing, “Iodoform gauze”.
Since then, Johnson & Johnson has continued to grow and is now one of the largest health care companies.
Further History: “In 1930, Johnson & Johnson gained the Massengill Company and by 1952, pharmaceuticals became part of Johnson & Johnson’s consumer division.
In 1959, because of the acquisition of McNeil Laboratories from Abbott Laboratories, pharmaceuticals became part of Johnson & Johnson’s Medical Devices and Diagnostics Division. In 1985, this division merged with its parent company, Johnson & Johnson.”
Developed in 2000, MUSTELA products result from the most advanced research-based on 40 years’ expertise in dermatology and pediatrics, providing safe & gentle formulations for babies (from birth), children (aged 3 months) and pregnant women that meet the highest quality, tolerance and biodegradability standards.
MUSTELA’s wide range of products ensures to meet all the daily skincare needs of babies, children and expectant mothers: cleansing, protecting, moisturizing and soothing.”
“The MUSTELA story began in 1953 when a group of dedicated scientists came together at Syntex Laboratories with a vision: to create gentle, perfect skincare for babies.
But why? Because they passionately believed that moms deserved products that were totally safe, totally simple and totally effective to care for their baby’s delicate skin.”
Mustela VS Aveeno Similarities
If you are looking for similarities between Mustela and Aveeno, here are some to consider:
1. Both brands contain gentle and natural ingredients:
Mustela: Water, Cetearyl Alcohol, Glycerin, Decyl Glucoside, Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil*, Cocoglycerides, Sucrose Laurate, Dicaprylyl Ether, Glyceryl Stearate Se, Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea Butter)* , Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil*, Algae Extract*, Avena Sativa (Oat) Kernel Flour*, Calendula Officinalis Flower Extract*, Chamomilla Recutita (Matricaria) Flower Extract*.
Aveeno: Active Naturals Calming Comfort Bath: Water, Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Cocamidopropyl Betaine, PEG-80 Glyceryl Cocoate, Sodium Chloride, Fragrance.
2. Both Companies Use Quality Ingredients
Mustela: most of the ingredients in Mustela products got naturally sourced and they try to stay away from any that might be potentially harmful to children, such as parabens, phthalates, perfumes or colorants.
Aveeno: we made Aveeno up of mostly natural ingredients and vegetable oils, so it makes sense that their products would be gentle enough for even sensitive skin.
3. Both Companies Make Many Types of Products
Mustela makes all kinds of products for babies, but we mostly designed them to help comfort them. Aveeno has a wide variety of skincare, bath and baby care products that are good for cleansing, moisturizing, soothing dryness, or targeting specific skin issues such as eczema.
4. Both Companies Have Great Reviews on the web
Mustela is a French Company which has been in the market for decades. They have family values, which is why their products are mild, even to the most sensitive skin.
They deliver quality products worldwide with great reviews about their business on the web. Aveeno: The product review section of the website shows just how many people love this brand.
There are over 2,300 reviews written by real customers who purchased Aveeno Baby Wash & Shampoo with natural oat extract.
5. Most People Agree Both Companies are Affordable
You can purchase Mustela products from various E-commerce sites online. One of the lowest prices is at Walmart for as little as $4.99.
Aveeno: In order to find out how much Aveeno could cost, I visited a big-box retailer and found that they were selling an 18-ounce container of Aveeno Baby Wash & Shampoo for around six bucks. That’s just about the same price you’ll pay for 10 ounces of Mustela.
6. Both Companies are Cruelty-Free
Mustela: Mustela is owned and produced by Laboratories Expanscience. Aveeno is owned by Johnson & Johnson, which has been in business for over 100 years and gets committed to making the world a better place for all of us. Aveeno is a brand that has been used for over 60 years.
Mustela VS Aveeno Lotions
Aveeno has the least medicinal scent; Mustela has a strong medicinal scent which is close to typical baby wipes and oily lotions (which evaporate after application).
Aveeno absorbs faster: It does not leave your child’s skin greasy for hours even if using it in morning and applying sunscreen at afternoon.
Mustela takes few hours to absorb, leaving your baby’s skin very oily and greasy throughout the day, especially if you apply it in the morning and then reapply sunscreens/sunblock’s in the afternoon.
So practically, both must get reapplied every 2-3 hours during summer in tropical climates, so you will have a hard time keeping your children out of the water without washing off all this oiliness from there.
Mustela VS Aveeno Wipes
The wipes have similar ingredients, but the Mustela wipes are fragrance-free, while some varieties of Aveeno baby wipes have an oatmeal scent added. Some varieties have aloe, which Mustela does not.
Mustela VS Aveeno Skin Cleansers
Mothers often recommend or consider both Mustela and Aveeno when they have a young baby. Mothers want the best for their precious little ones, so they look for certain things in products being used on their child’s skin.
The most common product recommendation is between newborns and Mustela products and then later on between toddlers and Aveeno products.
Mustela is a European brand, while Aveeno is an American brand. The two brands have different approaches in the development of their baby product lines.
Mustela has partnered with dermatologists and pediatricians to develop its products. Someone specially planned their products with plant-based ingredients and gentle cleansing agents.
The Aveeno brand has targeted skin irritations by creating oat proteins that protect irritated skin from further irritation.
Mustela VS Aveeno Eczema
Another consideration is eczema. Many customers buy baby products specifically made for this type of issue because it often occurs after babies are born due to exposure to harsh wipes or during their sensitive early years when their immune system is still learning to defend itself.
The ingredients for this type of issue should be simple and get selected with care:
Mustela’s rich and dense formula is made with non-hazardous substances (no parabens, no phthalates, no phenoxyethanol) and 90% of the total ingredients are of natural origin.
Aveeno uses oatmeal as their key ingredient, which has helped irritated skin but also contains petrolatum and fragrance – both harmful chemicals that can create more damage than good.
Mustela VS Aveeno Dry Skin
If you are looking for Mustela VS Aveeno for dry skin, consider this: Aveeno’s key ingredient is mineral oil-based petrolatum, a simple oil that can clog pores and cause breakouts.
Mustela’s lotion contains glycerin that can hold on to the water for longer periods of time than most other ingredients.
Both products contain shea butter, but only Mustela uses it with jojoba oil, which helps skin keep moisture while remaining soft instead of greasy.
Mustela VS Aveeno Ingredients
As far as ingredients go, though there are not exact Mustela VS Aveeno comparisons, here are some differences: Mustela uses mallow extract, which is soothing and can reduce redness associated with eczema.
Aveeno does not list their key ingredient even though it is petrolatum, which is a simple mixture of hydrocarbons that can suffocate skin and clog pores.
In addition, Aveeno uses Phenoxyethanol as a preservative and propylene glycol as an emulsifier- another ingredient that causes allergies and irritation.
Mustela VS Aveeno Pricing
The major difference between the cost of these 2 products is that Mustela offers a large variety of sizes, from travel size to very large container.
The average cost for Mustela’s product is around $12 – $40 dollars depending on the source you use, whereas Aveeno ranges from $4 – $20, with the larger containers being almost double the cost of Mustela.
Aveeno has the advantage of being available in drugstores, but I wouldn’t recommend purchasing smaller sizes often because it is not cost-effective. Mustela offers 90ml (3 oz) for nearly half the price per ounce that Aveeno does.
Suppose you’re looking for a gentle, hypoallergenic lotion to use on your baby’s delicate skin and want something that will also moisturize the skin. In that case, Aveeno Skin Relief Moisturizing Lotion is worth trying.
This product has been around since 1948 and got made with natural ingredients like oatmeal, chamomile extract, and colloidal oatmeal.
But if you’d prefer a brand-name drugstore option or just need an affordable price tag in order to justify buying it again when necessary, then Mustela Bebe Soft Cream might be more up your alley.
It contains no fragrance that can irritate sensitive babies’ noses but contains zinc oxide, which helps protect against sunburns.